If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Thermostat needle
Let me state my problem again with this.
Everyday I warm my car up for 5-15 minutes before driving. After approximately 2-5 minutes of driving the thermostat needle starts to slowly drop down to cold, the car down shifts by itself and the engine roars loudly becaue the RPM's are so high when the transmission down shifts. I took my 94 Mazda Miata to a Mazda dealer. They first said the thermostat was getting stuck. They checked that and that was not the problem. Then they did some type of engine cleaning (so they said)which cost me $74. The final analysis was I probably had a bent valve, which would have cost me $750 to repair. I elected not to repair, becaue this was an educated guess, but I wasn't interested in taking a stab in the dark for $750. Any ideas? |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Thermostat needle
Replace the thermostat. Even new ones may not work properly.
"2forgetmenot" > wrote in message lkaboutautos.com... > Let me state my problem again with this. > Everyday I warm my car up for 5-15 minutes before driving. After > approximately 2-5 minutes of driving the thermostat needle starts to > slowly drop down to cold, the car down shifts by itself and the engine > roars loudly becaue the RPM's are so high when the transmission down > shifts. I took my 94 Mazda Miata to a Mazda dealer. They first said the > thermostat was getting stuck. They checked that and that was not the > problem. Then they did some type of engine cleaning (so they said)which > cost me $74. The final analysis was I probably had a bent valve, which > would have cost me $750 to repair. I elected not to repair, becaue this > was an educated guess, but I wasn't interested in taking a stab in the > dark for $750. Any ideas? > |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Thermostat needle
In article
outautos.com>, "2forgetmenot" > wrote: > Let me state my problem again with this. > Everyday I warm my car up for 5-15 minutes before driving. After > approximately 2-5 minutes of driving the thermostat needle starts to > slowly drop down to cold, the car down shifts by itself and the engine > roars loudly becaue the RPM's are so high when the transmission down > shifts. I took my 94 Mazda Miata to a Mazda dealer. They first said the > thermostat was getting stuck. They checked that and that was not the > problem. Then they did some type of engine cleaning (so they said)which > cost me $74. The final analysis was I probably had a bent valve, which > would have cost me $750 to repair. I elected not to repair, becaue this > was an educated guess, but I wasn't interested in taking a stab in the > dark for $750. Any ideas? > Automatic transmission with an in-radiator cooler, presumably... Temp drop MIGHT have to do with the cold tranny-juice hitting the (already hot) radiator once you've put it in gear and the fluid starts circulating. Downshifts... Possibly the cold tranny fluid picking up heat from the radiator changes behavior - perhaps gets "thinner" suddenly - and alters the pressure it's putting on things enough to cause the downshift? High RPMs in the lower gear are to be expected, so the key is figuring out why the tranny is downshifting, I'd say. I'd strongly suspect that the temperature difference between the warmed-up engine and the cold tranny "mixing juices" in the radiator is responsible for the temp change, but I'm trying (and failing) to come up with some way that warming the tranny fluid could cause a downshift. What happens if you continue driving it? Does it "come back to normal" over the course of - oh, say 10-15 minutes (as the tranny comes up to full temperature)? or does the misbehavior continue indefinitely? -- Don Bruder - - If your "From:" address isn't on my whitelist, or the subject of the message doesn't contain the exact text "PopperAndShadow" somewhere, any message sent to this address will go in the garbage without my ever knowing it arrived. Sorry... <http://www.sonic.net/~dakidd> for more info |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Thermostat needle
In article
outautos.com>, "2forgetmenot" > wrote: > Everyday I warm my car up for 5-15 minutes before driving. After > approximately 2-5 minutes of driving the thermostat needle starts to > slowly drop down to cold What happens if you don't warm up the engine first? Letting it idle for longer than a few seconds is not necessary, and letting it idle for 15 minutes may actually be bad for the engine by promoting carbon deposits (hence the dealer's engine cleaning). Try starting the engine, waiting for the oil pressure gauge to level off--which takes less time than fastening your seatbelt--and then just driving off at a moderate pace. The engine should be warm enough for the heater to become useful within a mile or two, even in winter. Just try to keep it under 4000 rpm and avoid full throttle until the oil pressure drops and stabilizes around 55-60 psi at highway speeds. That's when you know everything is up to full operating temperature, and ready to accept a full load. That's how I treat my '94, and at 136k miles it runs better than new and uses zero oil between changes. -- Lanny Chambers '94C, St. Louis http://www.hummingbirds.net/alignment.html |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Thermostat needle
This sounds to me like a vaccum leak somewhere. Have you, or anyone
else, checked the engine for such a leak? Perhaps what's happening is that, despite the warmup period, the engine is still running below operational temperature when you start driving. Then, as it reaches operational temperature, the leak opens up enough to cause the problems you describe. If it's a vacuum leak, it shouldn't cost much to fix. "2forgetmenot" > wrote in message lkaboutautos.com... > Let me state my problem again with this. > Everyday I warm my car up for 5-15 minutes before driving. After > approximately 2-5 minutes of driving the thermostat needle starts to > slowly drop down to cold, the car down shifts by itself and the engine > roars loudly becaue the RPM's are so high when the transmission down > shifts. I took my 94 Mazda Miata to a Mazda dealer. They first said the > thermostat was getting stuck. They checked that and that was not the > problem. Then they did some type of engine cleaning (so they said)which > cost me $74. The final analysis was I probably had a bent valve, which > would have cost me $750 to repair. I elected not to repair, becaue this > was an educated guess, but I wasn't interested in taking a stab in the > dark for $750. Any ideas? > |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Thermostat needle
Oh, everyone forgot to mention, don't go back to that dealer! Well, at least
that's my humble opinion. Bent valve? Am I missing something or is the dealer blowing smoke up his _ _ _? I don't think you mentioned how many miles were on the car or when your last tranny service / fluid change was. Seems this could be a possibility before you start pouring $ down the dealers black hole. Good luck, Chris 99BBB 92BB&T for sale "Kenneth S." > wrote in message ... > This sounds to me like a vaccum leak somewhere. Have you, or anyone > else, checked the engine for such a leak? Perhaps what's happening is > that, despite the warmup period, the engine is still running below > operational temperature when you start driving. Then, as it reaches > operational temperature, the leak opens up enough to cause the problems > you describe. If it's a vacuum leak, it shouldn't cost much to fix. > > > "2forgetmenot" > wrote in message > lkaboutautos.com... >> Let me state my problem again with this. >> Everyday I warm my car up for 5-15 minutes before driving. After >> approximately 2-5 minutes of driving the thermostat needle starts to >> slowly drop down to cold, the car down shifts by itself and the engine >> roars loudly becaue the RPM's are so high when the transmission down >> shifts. I took my 94 Mazda Miata to a Mazda dealer. They first said the >> thermostat was getting stuck. They checked that and that was not the >> problem. Then they did some type of engine cleaning (so they said)which >> cost me $74. The final analysis was I probably had a bent valve, which >> would have cost me $750 to repair. I elected not to repair, becaue this >> was an educated guess, but I wasn't interested in taking a stab in the >> dark for $750. Any ideas? >> > > |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Thermostat needle
"Don Bruder" > wrote in message ... > In article >> > > Automatic transmission with an in-radiator cooler, presumably... > > Temp drop MIGHT have to do with the cold tranny-juice hitting the > (already hot) radiator once you've put it in gear and the fluid starts > circulating. "Tranny-juice" is moved aeound by a pump, connected directly to the engine. As such, it flows as soon as the crank rotates, not once a gear is selected. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Thermostat needle
In article >,
"Mal Osborne" > wrote: > "Don Bruder" > wrote in message > ... > > In article > >> > > > > Automatic transmission with an in-radiator cooler, presumably... > > > > Temp drop MIGHT have to do with the cold tranny-juice hitting the > > (already hot) radiator once you've put it in gear and the fluid starts > > circulating. > > "Tranny-juice" is moved aeound by a pump, connected directly to the engine. > As such, it flows as soon as the crank rotates, not once a gear is selected. > > Or maybe it's not, in this particular case? I'm grasping at straws trying to figure out why the temp gauge would drop suddenly after an extended warmup like the OP reported. The only thing I can think of would be the tranny being in gear somehow chilling the radiator, and in turn, the engine. Maybe I missed it, but I haven't seen any responses from him - I'd like to know whether it continues once the problem has started showing itself on a drive, or clears up, or what. -- Don Bruder - - If your "From:" address isn't on my whitelist, or the subject of the message doesn't contain the exact text "PopperAndShadow" somewhere, any message sent to this address will go in the garbage without my ever knowing it arrived. Sorry... <http://www.sonic.net/~dakidd> for more info |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Thermostat | [email protected] | Ford Explorer | 10 | November 1st 05 05:41 PM |
No thermostat in 96 Subaru Outback Wagon | rajp | Technology | 4 | October 12th 05 03:48 AM |
Thermostat problem on VUE | [email protected] | Saturn | 1 | January 10th 05 03:28 AM |
Need help to replace thermostat on 1993 325i sedan | Lyle_s | BMW | 7 | December 31st 04 10:30 AM |
e34 530 thermostat | mojo | BMW | 5 | October 3rd 04 09:20 PM |