If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
new battery - about 5yrs
Just replaced the battery in our 2001 Grand Cherokee.
So, the orig battery was 2001, then replaced at 2006, now again at 2012. This would imply a general life of about 5 or 6 years. Since I was stranded in a Home Depot parking lot, and had a really hard time jumping the battery and then keeping the engine from stalling out... for some reason... Would it be better to be pro-active and just replace batteries every 5 years, or wait for the eventual internal failure and being stranded... even with always having jumper cables -- / _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ No Good Deed - Goes Unpunished |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
new battery - about 5yrs
On 06/19/2012 11:32 AM, ps56k wrote:
> Just replaced the battery in our 2001 Grand Cherokee. > So, the orig battery was 2001, then replaced at 2006, now again at 2012. > > This would imply a general life of about 5 or 6 years. > > Since I was stranded in a Home Depot parking lot, > and had a really hard time jumping the battery > and then keeping the engine from stalling out... for some reason... > > Would it be better to be pro-active and just replace batteries every 5 > years, > or wait for the eventual internal failure and being stranded... even with > always having jumper cables > I live in Arizona and batteries get worked pretty hard. I'll go 4 years and replace. It depends a lot on your "climate". Consider it preventative maintenance. -- FRH |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
new battery - about 5yrs
Frank_v7.0 wrote:
> On 06/19/2012 11:32 AM, ps56k wrote: >> Just replaced the battery in our 2001 Grand Cherokee. >> So, the orig battery was 2001, then replaced at 2006, now again at >> 2012. This would imply a general life of about 5 or 6 years. >> >> Since I was stranded in a Home Depot parking lot, >> and had a really hard time jumping the battery >> and then keeping the engine from stalling out... for some reason... >> >> Would it be better to be pro-active and just replace batteries every >> 5 years, >> or wait for the eventual internal failure and being stranded... even >> with always having jumper cables >> > I live in Arizona and batteries get worked pretty hard. I'll go 4 > years and replace. It depends a lot on your "climate". Consider it > preventative maintenance. Roughly the same here. That's why I buy a high quality battery from Exide or Bosh with a 5-6 year warranty. (some times you can find them non pro-rated). About every four years I'm out another $30. Easy way to tell when the battery is going is to look at the sides. Batteries that are failing tend to swell and look "puffy". I take mine out to about 4 then start testing them every now and then for cranking amps and float. Fairly easy with the right tools and some places like PepBoys/Autozone/etc will test the battery they sell for free. -- DougW |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
new battery - about 5yrs
"DougW" > wrote in message ... > Frank_v7.0 wrote: >> On 06/19/2012 11:32 AM, ps56k wrote: >>> Just replaced the battery in our 2001 Grand Cherokee. >>> So, the orig battery was 2001, then replaced at 2006, now again at >>> 2012. This would imply a general life of about 5 or 6 years. >>> >>> Since I was stranded in a Home Depot parking lot, >>> and had a really hard time jumping the battery >>> and then keeping the engine from stalling out... for some reason... >>> >>> Would it be better to be pro-active and just replace batteries every >>> 5 years, >>> or wait for the eventual internal failure and being stranded... even >>> with always having jumper cables >>> >> I live in Arizona and batteries get worked pretty hard. I'll go 4 >> years and replace. It depends a lot on your "climate". Consider it >> preventative maintenance. > > Roughly the same here. > > That's why I buy a high quality battery from Exide or Bosh with a 5-6 year > warranty. (some times you can find them non pro-rated). About every four > years I'm out another $30. > > Easy way to tell when the battery is going is to look at the sides. > Batteries that are failing tend to swell and look "puffy". > > I take mine out to about 4 then start testing them every now and then > for cranking amps and float. Fairly easy with the right tools and > some places like PepBoys/Autozone/etc will test the battery they > sell for free. > > -- > DougW The yellow top Optima in my YJ is 10... PaulinVA > |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
new battery - about 5yrs
On 6/19/2012 1:32 PM, ps56k wrote:
> Just replaced the battery in our 2001 Grand Cherokee. > So, the orig battery was 2001, then replaced at 2006, now again at 2012. > > This would imply a general life of about 5 or 6 years. > > Since I was stranded in a Home Depot parking lot, > and had a really hard time jumping the battery > and then keeping the engine from stalling out... for some reason... > > Would it be better to be pro-active and just replace batteries every 5 > years, > or wait for the eventual internal failure and being stranded... even with > always having jumper cables > I generally buy a 5 or 6 year warranty battery, replace at the first signs of weak start any time after 4 years. If the battery give me ANY grief at the 3/4 mark, it is false economy to stretch it the least bit. Replacing it 'just because' is pushing my envelope a bit, can't argue with the general thought though. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
new battery - about 5yrs
On 6/19/2012 4:15 PM, Frank_v7.0 wrote:
> I live in Arizona and batteries get worked pretty hard. I'll go 4 years > and replace. It depends a lot on your "climate". Consider it > preventative maintenance. Here in NH it is not unusual to get 10 years from a battery. The battery in my wife's VW Cabriolet is 13 years old and that car starts up like a rocket (sure, I know it may die at almost any time, but so far so good...) The battery in my Dodge truck is 8 years old, gets beat because I plow with the truck, and still is going strong (I give that one a year more perhaps!) Climate is the main factor, colder climates make a battery very happy, hot ones bake it to death in a few years. -- I'm never going to grow up. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
new battery - about 5yrs
On 6/19/2012 10:33 PM, RoyJ wrote:
> > Replacing it 'just because' is pushing my envelope a bit, can't argue > with the general thought though. A lot of old folks remember when a battery gave you a warning before it dies. That is not true of the new batteries. Pick a life span that relates to it's quality and actually look at the cost. Even a $100 battery that only lasts 4 years has a cost of $.50 a week .. less than a cup of coffee and surely less than the hassle of sitting there waiting for assistance even if it does not cost you a bunch. -- AJ -- To argue with a person who has renounced the use of reason is like administering medicine to the dead. - Thomas Payne |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
new battery - about 5yrs
On Jun 19, 12:32*pm, "ps56k" > wrote:
> Just replaced the battery in our 2001 Grand Cherokee. > So, the orig battery was 2001, then replaced at 2006, now again at 2012. > > This would imply a general life of about 5 or 6 years. > > Since I was stranded in a Home Depot parking lot, > and had a really hard time jumping the battery > and then keeping the engine from stalling out... for some reason... > > Would it be better to be pro-active and just replace batteries every 5 > years, > or wait for the eventual internal failure and being stranded... even with > always having jumper cables > > -- > / _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ > No Good Deed - > * * * * *Goes Unpunished I got 5 years out of the first battery and two years out of the second one, so five years is sounding pretty good to me. Considering that alternators literally abuse a battery, i.e, charging to fast in cold weather, five years is really good. I also have a 2001 GC and when the battery is dead forget about attempting to drive it. There is not enough power to run the fuel pump unless you can keep the engine at a high idle. That is why you kept stalling out. I did mange to limp to the repair place once I was able to jump start it from my other jeep. BTW this happened just after I had the radiator cap fail leaving a lot of coolant on the driveway. So it was a weird time. Larry |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
new battery - about 5yrs
PeterD wrote:
> On 6/19/2012 4:15 PM, Frank_v7.0 wrote: >> I live in Arizona and batteries get worked pretty hard. I'll go 4 years >> and replace. It depends a lot on your "climate". Consider it >> preventative maintenance. > > Here in NH it is not unusual to get 10 years from a battery. The battery > in my wife's VW Cabriolet is 13 years old and that car starts up like a > rocket (sure, I know it may die at almost any time, but so far so > good...) The battery in my Dodge truck is 8 years old, gets beat because > I plow with the truck, and still is going strong (I give that one a year > more perhaps!) > > Climate is the main factor, colder climates make a battery very happy, > hot ones bake it to death in a few years. Sounds pretty close to my experience in Colorado. When I bought the MJ the dealer put in a new battery - obviously the cheapest one he could find - and it lasted right at 10 years. The replacement Excide unit is 5 years old now and still tests at 100% rated capacity. Biggest killer for me has always been the mount. If the battery can bounce around it usually goes in a hurry. -- Will Honea |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
new battery - about 5yrs
Larry wrote:
> On Jun 19, 12:32 pm, "ps56k" > wrote: >> Just replaced the battery in our 2001 Grand Cherokee. >> So, the orig battery was 2001, then replaced at 2006, now again at 2012. >> >> This would imply a general life of about 5 or 6 years. >> >> Since I was stranded in a Home Depot parking lot, >> and had a really hard time jumping the battery >> and then keeping the engine from stalling out... for some reason... >> >> Would it be better to be pro-active and just replace batteries every 5 >> years, >> or wait for the eventual internal failure and being stranded... even with >> always having jumper cables >> >> -- >> / _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ _/ >> No Good Deed - >> Goes Unpunished > > I got 5 years out of the first battery and two years out of the second > one, so five years is sounding pretty good to me. Considering that > alternators literally abuse a battery, i.e, charging to fast in cold > weather, five years is really good. > > I also have a 2001 GC and when the battery is dead forget about > attempting to drive it. There is not enough power to run the fuel > pump unless you can keep the engine at a high idle. That is why you > kept stalling out. > > I did mange to limp to the repair place once I was able to jump start > it from my other jeep. > > BTW this happened just after I had the radiator cap fail leaving a lot > of coolant on the driveway. So it was a weird time. After flying a/c maintenance flights for years, I'm one of those that carries around one of those jump-start units. Good for 3-4 starts on a charge, it can also be dropped in under the hood to get you home as it charges just fine off the alternator. It's also a whole lot more convenient than jumper cables when others need a jump so it's worth the $30 - $40 for one of the Harbor Freight units. -- Will Honea |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Best battery deals in Canada? Solar chargers drain the battery in the dark? | Calab | Technology | 10 | July 14th 08 07:36 PM |
Brand new battery, battery light still comes ON and off | adf | Honda | 3 | February 11th 06 04:26 AM |
Can I replace an OEM starter battery with a Deep Cycle Marine battery? | Lawrence Glickman | Technology | 31 | December 1st 05 06:30 AM |
To trickle or Not Trickle! please help a battery noobie with a 12v Gel battery question | rutman | Technology | 29 | May 5th 05 10:38 PM |
When The Battery Light Comes On Does This Mean The Battery Is Going Dead? | John | Saturn | 10 | August 14th 04 01:25 AM |