If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
300 M Battery Replacement?
I have a '99 , 300M - took delivery in August 1998... Still has the original
battery and it seems to be doing fine. Anyone in ths group ever change out the battery on 300M... advice appreciated... thanks -- The novelist George Eliot once said that "it is never too late to become what you might have been." |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
300 M Battery Replacement?
NewsGroup wrote:
> I have a '99 , 300M - took delivery in August 1998... Still has the original > battery and it seems to be doing fine. Anyone in ths group ever change out > the battery on 300M... advice appreciated... thanks Yep (well - a '99 Concorde - same car as far as battery replacement). The by-the-book procedure is to jack up and remove the passenger side front wheel, remove the fender liner, open the hood and remove the air filter box (for access to cable clamps from above), then scoot the battery rearward and bring it out thru the wheel well. Some prefer to leave the wheel totally alone, remove air filter box, then tilt the battery up lengthwise and pull it up thru that hole. In this case, I go by the book - too much chance of battery acid spillage using the shortcut method. If you don't mind spending around $120 (total, including shipping or sales tax as the case may be), you might do what I did and get an Optima (you would want the Model 34, P/N 8002-002) so you won't ever have to mess with it again. Bill Putney (To reply by e-mail, replace the last letter of the alphabet in my address with the letter 'x') |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
300 M Battery Replacement?
"Bill Putney" > wrote in message ... > NewsGroup wrote: > >> I have a '99 , 300M - took delivery in August 1998... Still has the >> original battery and it seems to be doing fine. Anyone in ths group >> ever change out the battery on 300M... advice appreciated... thanks > > Yep (well - a '99 Concorde - same car as far as battery replacement). The > by-the-book procedure is to jack up and remove the passenger side front > wheel, remove the fender liner, open the hood and remove the air filter > box (for access to cable clamps from above), then scoot the battery > rearward and bring it out thru the wheel well. Some prefer to leave the > wheel totally alone, remove air filter box, then tilt the battery up > lengthwise and pull it up thru that hole. In this case, I go by the > book - too much chance of battery acid spillage using the shortcut method. > > If you don't mind spending around $120 (total, including shipping or sales > tax as the case may be), you might do what I did and get an Optima (you > would want the Model 34, P/N 8002-002) so you won't ever have to mess with > it again. > > Bill Putney > (To reply by e-mail, replace the last letter of the alphabet in my address > with the letter 'x') Nothing special about the Optima. Just make sure you pick up a fresh sealed battery [without vent caps]. NAPA and Wal-Mart batteries did well in the last round of tests by Consumer Reports. Sears batteries, now supplied by a new vender, did not do very well at all. Richard. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
300 M Battery Replacement?
Richard wrote:
> "Bill Putney" > wrote in message > ... >>If you don't mind spending around $120 (total, including shipping or sales >>tax as the case may be), you might do what I did and get an Optima (you >>would want the Model 34, P/N 8002-002) so you won't ever have to mess with >>it again. > > Nothing special about the Optima. Just make sure you pick up a fresh sealed > battery [without vent caps]. NAPA and Wal-Mart batteries did well in the > last round of tests by Consumer Reports. Sears batteries, now supplied by a > new vender, did not do very well at all. Nothing personal, but you speak from total ignorance. The Optima is different in several good ways. (Let me guess - Consumer Reports said there was nothing special about the Optima. Figures.) Optima (compared to "traditional" battery): **VERY** **VERY** robust mechanically and electrically, and smaller physical size. Lasts 10+ years (vs. typically 3 to 5 years). It is what is referred to as a gel cell, not liquid electrolyte like the batteries that you are ignorantly comparing it to. Also, FWIW, you can safely put an Optima in an occupied passenger compartment and not have to worry about toxic acid fumes endangering health or eating holes in fabrics. You can mount an Optima in any orientation. Other than those things mentioned above - you're right - nothing speical about an Optima. Bill Putney (To reply by e-mail, replace the last letter of the alphabet in my address with the letter 'x') |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
300 M Battery Replacement?
Richard wrote:
> "Bill Putney" > wrote in message > ... > > NewsGroup wrote: > > > >> I have a '99 , 300M - took delivery in August 1998... Still has the > >> original battery and it seems to be doing fine. Anyone in ths group > >> ever change out the battery on 300M... advice appreciated... thanks > > > > Yep (well - a '99 Concorde - same car as far as battery replacement). The > > by-the-book procedure is to jack up and remove the passenger side front > > wheel, remove the fender liner, open the hood and remove the air filter > > box (for access to cable clamps from above), then scoot the battery > > rearward and bring it out thru the wheel well. Some prefer to leave the > > wheel totally alone, remove air filter box, then tilt the battery up > > lengthwise and pull it up thru that hole. In this case, I go by the > > book - too much chance of battery acid spillage using the shortcut method. > > > > If you don't mind spending around $120 (total, including shipping or sales > > tax as the case may be), you might do what I did and get an Optima (you > > would want the Model 34, P/N 8002-002) so you won't ever have to mess with > > it again. > > > > Bill Putney > > (To reply by e-mail, replace the last letter of the alphabet in my address > > with the letter 'x') > > Nothing special about the Optima. Just make sure you pick up a fresh sealed > battery [without vent caps]. NAPA and Wal-Mart batteries did well in the > last round of tests by Consumer Reports. Sears batteries, now supplied by a > new vender, did not do very well at all. I saw that Consumer Reports article. I was confused by it, since it the same battery was all over their charts under different brand names. But that's CR for you. Most Sears batteries (including the Gold Diehard) are now made by Johnson Controls. They used to be made by Exide 4+ years ago, but Exide had some major quality control problems and contracted specifications were not met. Legal disputes ensued (customer vs. Sears Roebuck, and Sears Roebuck vs Exide) and Sears found a new vendor. JCI also makes Optima. Most auto batteries in the USA today are made by either JCI or Exide, with a handful of smaller players. I'm not sure if either is better now. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
300 M Battery Replacement?
Bill Putney wrote:
> NewsGroup wrote: > > > I have a '99 , 300M - took delivery in August 1998... Still has the original > > battery and it seems to be doing fine. Anyone in ths group ever change out > > the battery on 300M... advice appreciated... thanks > > Yep (well - a '99 Concorde - same car as far as battery replacement). > The by-the-book procedure is to jack up and remove the passenger side > front wheel, remove the fender liner, open the hood and remove the air > filter box (for access to cable clamps from above), then scoot the > battery rearward and bring it out thru the wheel well. Some prefer to > leave the wheel totally alone, remove air filter box, then tilt the > battery up lengthwise and pull it up thru that hole. In this case, I go > by the book - too much chance of battery acid spillage using the > shortcut method. Point of clarification, the factory service manual (and the owner's manual for that manner) says not to remove the wheel. I think the aftermarket books say the opposite. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
300 M Battery Replacement?
Sears sells the Optimas both yellow and red tops also yo can get them at
Advanced Auto stores. -- Coasty Remove the SPOOGE to reply "Bill Putney" > wrote in message ... > NewsGroup wrote: > >> I have a '99 , 300M - took delivery in August 1998... Still has the >> original battery and it seems to be doing fine. Anyone in ths group >> ever change out the battery on 300M... advice appreciated... thanks > > Yep (well - a '99 Concorde - same car as far as battery replacement). The > by-the-book procedure is to jack up and remove the passenger side front > wheel, remove the fender liner, open the hood and remove the air filter > box (for access to cable clamps from above), then scoot the battery > rearward and bring it out thru the wheel well. Some prefer to leave the > wheel totally alone, remove air filter box, then tilt the battery up > lengthwise and pull it up thru that hole. In this case, I go by the > book - too much chance of battery acid spillage using the shortcut method. > > If you don't mind spending around $120 (total, including shipping or sales > tax as the case may be), you might do what I did and get an Optima (you > would want the Model 34, P/N 8002-002) so you won't ever have to mess with > it again. > > Bill Putney > (To reply by e-mail, replace the last letter of the alphabet in my address > with the letter 'x') |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
300 M Battery Replacement?
Originally posted Sept 2004:
Executive summary: 1) If you want a lot of reserve capacity, you probably have no choice but will end up getting a battery with lot of CCA. 2) Get the biggest, heaviest battery that will fit in your car. 3) The Reserve Capacity may be a better predictor of battery capacity than the CCA rating. 4) Unless the newer spiral-wound batteries have inherently higher energy densities, then their CCA and RC numbers are bogus and you are making a trade-off (lower CCA's and RC's) vs getting a battery that probably is better for off-roading and vibration tolerance but is no better (durability-wise) for passenger car use than a standard AGM (Absorbed Glass Mat) battery. 5) When selecting a battery off-the-shelf, get the "freshest" or newest date-code the retailer has in the store. This may mean the battery you want is in the back room and not on the rack in front of you. Date code explanations for particular brands are further down this post. Consult the internet if you can't find what you're looking for. Perhaps the best time to buy a battery is when a retailer has sold a bunch to other customers (clearing their older inventory). This presumably would be during mid or late winter. ------------------------- I don't necessarily believe that the Optima line of batteries is the "best" from an energy density point of view (the spiral design does not make the best use of the available rectangular exterior envelope compared to conventional battery construction). It might very well be that shelf-life was the over-riding design criteria for this battery. Shelf life is probably _the_ most important issue for retailers. Cold Cranking Amps (CCA) and reserve capacity are probably the two most important numbers to look at when selecting a battery since other objective criteria, like MTBF, accelerated life tests (vibration and temperature extremes) are not readily available to compare across manufacturers. Unlike many other types of consumer products (digital cameras, car tires, many electronic product, etc) there are no third-party-operated web sites that track, organize, and tabulate the experience of consumers when it comes to car batteries, let alone take the batteries apart and make subjective comparisons between manufacturers (as has been done with oil filters for example). This web site: http://www.bgsoflex.com/cca.htm will give you the CCA number given engine size and # of cylinders as inputs. For example, a 3.5L V-6 (214 cubic inches) gives a computed CCA of 285. It is generally the consensus that you should NOT sacrifice reserve capacity for the sake of having a large CCA. For example, if I had the choice between the following batteries: A) 400 CCA and 120 minutes reserve capacity B) 800 CCA and 90 minutes reserve capacity Then it seems that battery (A) will, in the long run, be a better choice because I'm not likely to ever need more than 400 CCA while on the other hand the extra 30 minutes of reserve capacity may actually be needed at some point. In other words, batteries can never convert un-needed CCA's into extra reserve minutes. One thing must always be kept in mind. Once you choose a battery make and model, buy the "freshest" battery in store (which, it seems, will not necessarily be on the battery rack but instead in the back room). I found the following web site to have useful battery information: http://www.uuhome.de/william.darden/ And particulary these pages: http://www.uuhome.de/william.darden/batbrand.htm http://www.uuhome.de/william.darden/carfaq7.htm#rc This paragraph is interesting: ---------- 7.6. Freshness Lead-acid batteries are perishable and sulfate in storage due to their natural self discharge. Please see Section 16 for more information on sulfation. Determining the "freshness" of a battery is sometimes difficult. Unless it has been periodically recharged or "dry charged", NEVER buy a wet Standard (Sb/Sb) or Low Maintenance (Sb/Ca) battery that is MORE than three months old or a wet Maintenance Free (Ca/Ca) battery that is MORE than six months old. Dry charged batteries are shipped without electrolyte, but usually have "sell by" dates of one to three years. Depending on the temperature, AGM and Gel Cell batteries that can be stored six to 18 months before the State-of-Charge drops below 80%. Please see Section 16. for more information on sulfation. Dealers will place their older batteries in storage racks so they will sell first and they do not have to maintain them. The fresher batteries can be found in the rear of the battery rack or in a storage room. For a wet battery, the date of formation is often stamped on the case or printed on a sticker. Always have a new battery tested, and recharged if necessary, before you leave the store. This can save you a lot of time and frustration if the new battery is sulfated or has a manufacturing defect. -------------- Here is the complete section on battery date codes: ------------ The battery date codes for various manufacturers is perhaps the most useful information to have when you're actually at the parts counter about to buy a battery. Some of the manufacturer's formation date coding techniques are as follows: 7.6.1. Delphi (ACDelco) and some Sears DieHard Dates are stamped on the cover near one post. The first number is the year. The second character is the month A-M, skipping I. The last two characters indicate geographic areas. For example, 0BN3=2000 February. [Source: Interstate Batteries] 7.6.2. Douglas Douglas uses the letters of their name to indicate the year of manufacture and the digits 1-12 for the month. D=1994 O=1995 U=1996 G=1997 L=1998 A=1999 S=2000 For example, S02=2000 Feb. 7.6.3. East Penn, Exide (Champion), Johnson Controls Inc., Interstate, Mopar (Chrysler) and some Sears DieHard) Usually on a sticker or hot-stamped on the side of the case. A=January, B=February, and the letter I is skipped. The number next to the letter is the year of shipment. For example, B0=Feb 2000. [Source: Interstate Batteries] 7.6.4. Exide (some Sears non-Gold DieHards) The fourth or fifth character is the month. The following numeric character is the year. A-M skipping I. For example, RO8B0B=February 2000. [Source: Interstate Batteries] 7.6.5. Optima The first character is the year. The following three numeric characters are the days of the year. For example, 3123=3 May 2003. 7.6.6. Trojan The date code on the negative post is stamped as the battery comes off of the finishing line, ready to ship out or go into stock. The code that is stamped is usually one month ahead. Therefore, a battery that comes out in March will carry an April date code. The code on the positive post is the manufacturing date that indicates when the battery was physically built but before the addition of any electrolyte. The letter is the month (A=Jan, B=Feb, C=March, etc.) and the number is the actual date. So "K26" means that the battery was ready for electrolyte filling and the first forming charge was on November 26th. Since the negative post shows A2 (January 2002), the manufacturing year has to be 2001. 7.6.7. Concorde The activation date is on an orange sticker the shipping carton or email Concorde Customer Service with the serial number of the battery. 7.6.8. Rolls and Surrette The four digit date code represents the day of the week (first digit), week of the year (middle two digits) and the year (last digit). For example, April 4, 2003 would have 4143 as a date code. The date code is stamped into the front edge of the cover of the battery. ------------------------ I can't see how all Spiral Wound AGM (Absorbed Glass Mat) batteries _wouldn't_ be lighter than regular rectangular batteries of the same external size. FYI - Excide also seems to make a spiral-wound battery (Select Orbital): http://www.exideworld.com/products/a...t_orbital.html Using the numbers from the specs for the Exide ORB78D-84, I get a predicted weight of 44 lbs, where according to it's specs it weighs 38 lbs. I found some specs on "DayStarter" batteries (St. Paul, Minnesota) and their group-34 battery has 600 CCA and RC of 110 minutes. The following was computed based on data from 19 batteries in a list of 12-volt passenger car and light commercial battery specifications (January 2004) from http://www.daystarter.com/. Battery weight vs Battery volume: Weight = 0.0716 x V + 2.9 (r = .86) Where V is the volume (in cubic inches) of the battery calculated by multiplying the length by width by height. Volumes ranged from 432 to 734 cubic inches, and weights ranged from 34 to 56 lbs. So (as expected) battery volume and weight correlate pretty well. CCA vs weight: CCA = 8.54 x W + 212 (r = .807) Where W is the battery weight (in lbs) and CCA is the Cold Cranking Amp rating at 0 degrees F. Interesting that it predicts 212 CCA at zero battery weight. CCA vs volume: CCA = .647 x V + 218 (r = .778) Where V is battery volume (in cubic inches). Again it predicts a CCA of a little over 200 at zero battery volume. Weight is slightly better than external volume at predicting a battery's CCA. Regarding reserve capacity (RC): RC vs weight: RC = 2.88 x W - 23 (r = .885) Where RC is reserve capacity (in minutes) and W is battery weight (lbs). RC vs volume: RC = .216 x V - 20 (r = .836) Where V is battery volume (cubic inches). Again weight is slightly better than external battery volume at predicting reserve capacity. Interesting that at zero weight and volume that it predicts about negative 20 for RC. How does CCA correspond to RC? RC = .317 x CCA - 83 (r = .968) It's the strongest correlation. So, what does all this mean? 1) Big batteries weigh more (tone down the wise-cracks) 2) Both weight and volume correspond with higher CCA's and higher RC. 3) CCA's correspond strongly with RC. 4) RC correlates better with both weight and volume than CCA does. 5) I'm thinking that Daystarter inflates their CCA by 200, and their RC by 20 minutes (judging by the zero intercept of these graphs). Executive summary: 1) If you want a lot of reserve capacity, you probably have no choice but will get a lot of CCA with it. 2) Get the biggest, heaviest battery that will fit in your car. 3) The Reserve Capacity may be a better predictor of battery capacity than the CCA rating. 4) Unless the newer spiral-wound batteries have inherently higher energy densities, then their CCA and RC numbers are bogus and you are making a trade-off (lower CCA's and RC's) vs getting a battery that probably is better for off-roading and vibration tolerance but is no better (durability-wise) for passenger car use than a standard AGM (Absorbed Glass Mat) battery. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
300 M Battery Replacement?
Coasty wrote:
> Sears sells the Optimas both yellow and red tops also yo can get them at > Advanced Auto stores. You have to watch your pricing and model for the best deal. When I replaced my battery a couple of years ago, Advance listed the Optima 34 at $175 - out of the question. But I did an on-line search and found that there were suppliers with shared warehouses distributed around the country so that anyone in the U.S. was within 1 day UPS ground shipment - price with shipping: under $120. Advance only stocks the 34/78 (dual terminal - top and side) version to cut down on inventory items. IIRC, the 34/78 is about the same price as the 34, but you sacrifice cranking amps - so you're essentially paying for the extra terminals that you won't use. Better to shop on line for the 34 for the best bang for the buck. Not sure which one(s) Sears stocks and their pricing. Bill Putney (To reply by e-mail, replace the last letter of the alphabet in my address with the letter 'x') |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
300 M Battery Replacement?
If your examples (400 CCA, RC 120; 800 CCA, RC 90) are somewhat typical
of AGM's, then it would seem that the Optima 34's 800 CCA (0°F)/1000MCA (32°F) and RC of 120 minutes stacks up pretty well. Also - it is considrably smaller (10" x 6.9" x 7.8") than the OEM 600 CCA, RC 120 AGM battery that it replaced - would that (smaller size, similar or better electrical performance) not indicate higher energy density? Not to mention that the Optima will easiy last 2 to 3 times longer. Bill Putney (To reply by e-mail, replace the last letter of the alphabet in my address with the letter 'x') MoPar Man wrote: > 1) If you want a lot of reserve capacity, you probably have no choice > but will end up getting a battery with lot of CCA. > > 2) Get the biggest, heaviest battery that will fit in your car. > > 3) The Reserve Capacity may be a better predictor of battery capacity > than the CCA rating. > > 4) Unless the newer spiral-wound batteries have inherently higher > energy densities, then their CCA and RC numbers are bogus and > you are making a trade-off (lower CCA's and RC's) vs getting > a battery that probably is better for off-roading and vibration > tolerance but is no better (durability-wise) for passenger car > use than a standard AGM (Absorbed Glass Mat) battery. > > 5) When selecting a battery off-the-shelf, get the "freshest" or > newest date-code the retailer has in the store. This may mean > the battery you want is in the back room and not on the rack > in front of you. Date code explanations for particular brands > are further down this post. Consult the internet if you can't > find what you're looking for. Perhaps the best time to buy a > battery is when a retailer has sold a bunch to other customers > (clearing their older inventory). This presumably would be > during mid or late winter. > For example, if I had > the choice between the following batteries: > > A) 400 CCA and 120 minutes reserve capacity > B) 800 CCA and 90 minutes reserve capacity > > Then it seems that battery (A) will, in the long run, be a better > choice because I'm not likely to ever need more than 400 CCA while on > the other hand the extra 30 minutes of reserve capacity may actually > be needed at some point. In other words, batteries can never convert > un-needed CCA's into extra reserve minutes. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Replacement Battery '92 Accord Question | [email protected] | Honda | 12 | June 24th 05 06:07 AM |
Stupid Viper Alarm Starter Kill won't let me start car after battery replacement.. HELP! | [email protected] | Technology | 3 | March 28th 05 04:08 AM |
Battery replacement comments and questions | Tom's VR6 | VW water cooled | 1 | November 12th 04 06:12 PM |
battery question | Jim Beaver | General | 14 | November 6th 04 10:54 PM |
540I key fob battery replacement | Barbara McMahon | BMW | 1 | September 27th 04 05:18 PM |